BCS Know How’s CFP vs. BCS
Every ranking since 2014, side by side

Yes, but only in one real way.

We stacked every committee ranking since 2014 against the BCS formula and the polls, then stress-tested the gaps with the same statistics researchers use. Only one pattern held up.

How the committee moves each group, vs. the BCS sim

The BCS sim is zero. Each bar is how many spots the committee ranks a group higher (+, to the right) or lower (−, to the left) than the sim does, on average, 2014 to 2025. If the black line crosses zero, the gap could be noise.

Year by year

How we know, and what we can't know
  • The BCS-style sim is not the truth. It blends human polls and computers, so a bias the polls share would not show up here.
  • The results column is our own model built from game scores and schedules. It does not know about injuries, availability or how a team looked.
  • A committee can have a good reason for a different order. This page shows where they differ, not why.
  • The non-power finding holds against the sim, the polls and the game results, with and without the 2020 and 2021 COVID seasons.
  • 2026 is only three releases so far.